I spent six years working at Target, most of them in electronics. Of all the products I handled during those years, one package I still remember is the box for the first iPod with video.
Guests would pick it up, turn it over once or twice, and decide. I remember how little explaining I had to do. Apple already had people walking into the store interested in an iPod. The box can’t take credit for that. But once a guest had it in hand, they could see what this version added and decide whether they wanted to spend the money.
I appreciated that on days when I was helping someone compare two other models. If the less expensive one looked almost identical, it was fair to ask what you got for the extra money. I could walk someone through it while I was standing there. The next guest looking at those same two boxes might have to wait until I was free.
Years later, I came back to Target from the vendor side for line reviews. We bid on business and didn’t win the shelf space. Looking back, I think we expected a lot from our brand story. We had time in a presentation to explain why the product belonged. A guest in electronics would never hear that presentation.
It’s a test I still like for a product review. Put your box beside the one a shopper is most likely to compare it with. Let someone pick up both and decide which one they’d buy. Before anyone on the team starts explaining, I’d watch for the thing I remember those Target guests doing. What did they turn the box over to find?